Scott Derrickson Vanishes From Doctor Strange 2: Creative Differences or Creative Control

Another innovative director bites the dust as Scott Derrickson parts ways with Marvel over creative differences with Doctor Strange and The Multiverse of Madness.

This one hurt.

When Derrickson was announced for the first movie I was beyond excited, Marvel had hired a horror movie director and I couldn’t wait to see what would come from it. Unfortunately, what we got was a pretty tame version of the Sorcerer Supreme that was packaged so safe you could almost feel the bubble wrap.

I was a bit disappointed, but still it wasn’t a terrible movie and it had a great cast. Besides Marvel has a track record of playing a movie a bit safe before releasing more control to their directors (Captain America: Winter Soldier is a perfect example of this).

Time went on and the next couple of times we saw Strange was in Thor Ragnarok and Avengers Infinity War — I was filled with hope as I saw both Waititi and the Russo Brothers dive into the weirdness of the character and actually let him do some magic.

And then the icing on the cake: Comic-Con happened and the title for Strange’s sequel was released Doctor Strange and the Multiverse of Madness. A title that was weird, 80s-esque and best of all, Derrickson described it as Marvel’s first horror movie. I was floored.

Then the news came in a few months later that Derrickson had left the project. While he’s still remaining on as executive producer, I’m guessing that’s in-name-only.

It got me thinking though, why doesn’t Disney trust their directors? Thankfully, Marvel seems way more open to playing ball than Lucasfilm does (currently Lucasfilm has fired around ten directors within five years), but Marvel is definitely not without fault here either.

2015’s Ant-Man was ready to start shooting when Edgar Wright left the project for the same reasons. Now I get that big studios want to make sure they maximize their box-office returns, but it’s strange to me that Marvel seems to want to take chances with their flagship Avengers series, but play it so safe with their lesser-known characters.

You would think they would have learned their lesson with Thor after the wildly successful Ragnarok.

Oh well, at the end of the day the movie hasn’t come out yet and hopefully, it’s still as good and innovative as it can be.


  • While a great many would see him as a hero, there are some that would prefer the term vigilante. Gregory is an aspiring filmmaker who loves writing, directing, coffee and long walks on the beach.


    You May Also Like

    Forget About Tomorrow, Set Your Sights On Yesterday

    Yesterday is one of those movies that takes an innovative premise and just runs ...

    Small Beginnings: Catherine Hardwicke

    Let’s look at one of the many talented female directors in Hollywood, unfortunately not ...

    Movies that Made Me Fall in Love with Film

    What are the movies that inspired you to fall in love with the world ...

    The Reason Why You Should Watch Blood Diamond

    Blood Diamond was, and still is, an innovative film. Here’s why.

    3 Movies That Will Make You Want To Travel

    Check out these three movies, it might be an inspiration for your next vacation.

    Don't want to miss a thing?

    Subscribe and join our creative community to keep updated with our weekly-ish* Newsletter from The Independent Initiative.

    *We're filmmakers, sometimes we're out filming something, on those weeks the newsletters might be more irregular. Follow The Initiative Production Company (theInitiativePro) on your favorite social media to stay the most up to date on our current productions